Alec Guinness and John Mills were both too old for their roles in
Great Expectations, but were convincing nevertheless.
Alec Guinness was too old for the flashback sequences in
Doctor Zhivago. His scenes as the narrator work well at the beginning and the end, but a brief scene where he is supposed to be a young man joining up at the beginnig of the Great War is startlinsly unconvincing.
This does seem to happen often: Guinness was miscast in some way in several of David Lean's films. His appearance as a Hindu (


) in
A Passage to Indiawas a weird, totally unconvincing - and tasteless - anomaly in an otherwise excellent film. It was like a Peter Sellers or John Cleese routine. I literally couldn't believe my eyes. His Arab in
Lawrence of Arabia was slightly better: at least it wasn't laughable.
Roger Livesey was too old for the role in
I Know Where I'm Going. He is specifically referred to as a man in his 20s, which was obviously not the case. If there had been no reference, it wouldn't have mattered - odd.
Edith Evans is much too old for the role of Aunt Betsy in the terrible television production of
David Copperfield. That show really was unbelievably terrible. It features almost every major actor and actress in Britain, but it reduces a geat novel to a flashback and series of vignettes.
Very, very disappointing.
She is one of my favorite characters in all of literature. Evans would have been a fine choice when she was in her 60s, but she was in her 80s and seemed frail. The one thing Aunt Betsy is
NOT is frail. It was sad.