Are these the best British films ever?

[julian_craster]

The magnificent seven..... Are these the best British films ever?





In celebration of British cinema, the UK Film Council is re-releasing some of our greatest movies. Geoffrey Macnab reviews their selections. Do you agree?



Published: 11 July 2007

From The Independent

The magnificent seven? Are these the best British films ever? - Independent Online Edition > Features



Comedy: Withnail & I

On the grounds that Johnny Depp likes it and that there are fans who can recite backwards every line uttered by Uncle Monty (Richard Griffiths), Withnail and I, right, can safely be described as the most cultish British film comedy in living memory. Its great virtue is that it is funny. One of the continuing mysteries of British film history is why so many talented British comedians from music hall, variety and (latterly) TV appear to lose their powers to make us laugh as soon as they are confronted with a movie camera.

Thankfully, this is a trend that the likes of Simon Pegg and Edgar Wright are succeeding in reversing. We should also remember that we have quite a long heritage in the comedy department. Charlie Chaplin - the most successful screen comedian of all time - was born not far from the Elephant and Castle. Kind Hearts And Coronets - the best-written film comedy of all - was made at Ealing Studios.







Costume drama: Henry V

The UK Film Council and the BBC have opted for Laurence Olivier's Henry V (right) as the quintessential British costume drama. Made during the war, it is certainly superior propaganda. Listening to Olivier exhort his troops (" we few, we happy few, we band of brothers") on St Crispin's Day is enough to make you want to jump off the sofa and invade France all over again. Even so, this is surely not the peak of British costume drama.

It took a Hungarian to teach the Brits how best to make movies about men in tights. Alexander Korda's The Private Life of Henry VIII (1933), for which Charles Laughton won an Oscar, was the first British costume picture to make any kind of dent in the US market. What Korda realised was that pomp and battles are all very well, but if you really want to sell your picture, you need some action in the bedroom. The US marketing campaign was imaginative, if misogynistic. Cinemas were encouraged to exploit the movie on its title and its portrayal of the Bluebeard of kings who married six women and caused two of them to pay for their infidelity under the axe of the executioner. It's a costume piece, but only in its setting.





Social realism: Billy Liar

Billy Liar sets the question that every young male dreamer from the provinces must have asked himself: when Julie Christie invites you to board the train and seek your fortune in London, will you go? The film, though, spends so much time exploring Tom Courtenay's fantasy life that it is debatable whether it can strictly be defined as social realism.

You won't find any whimsy in Lindsay Anderson's bruising, utterly uncompromising This Sporting Life, right. The star of the film, Richard Harris, had clearly been mugging up on his Marlon Brando to portray the rugby league player Frank Machin. British audiences accustomed to British cinema's holy trinity of tweed-jacketed, flannel trouser-wearing chaps, Dirk Bogarde, Kenneth More and Jack Hawkins, were blown away by the sheer physical intensity of Harris's performance. "It has a blow like a fist," the critic Penelope Gilliat wrote of the film. "I've never seen an English picture which gave such expression to the violence and capacity for pain that there is in the English character." Counterpointing Harris's bruising machismo, there was a wonderfully poignant performance from the Welsh actress Rachel Roberts as the widow Mrs Hammond, whose husband died in an industrial accent. He woos her. She scorns him. The suffering he experiences because of her is far worse than anything he experiences on the rugby field - or, for that matter, on the dentist's chair.







Horror/Fantasy: The Wicker Man

The Wicker Man is memorable for the confrontation between Edward Woodward's heroically prudish presbyterian policeman, and Britt Ekland, paganism and combustible Antony Gormley-like sculptures. It is frightening enough in its Highland way, even if - like many cult films that have been the victim of remakes - it suffers from a certain over-familiarity.

In the canon of British horror, however, there are other equally chilling films. You could start with Ealing Studios' Dead Of Night, above, still arguably the best portmanteau picture ever made and justly celebrated for Michael Redgrave's turn as the ventriloquist persecuted by his dummy. Witchfinder General, the last film from young British horrormeister Michael Reeves before his untimely death in 1969, boasts a supremely creepy performance from Vincent Price as the witchfinder in Civil War-era England. If you like a horror film that's also a a ripping yarn, you will relish Terence Fisher's The Devil Rides Out. The sequences of Christopher Lee and co in their pentangle, trying to withstand evil forces conjured up by the diabolic Charles Gray (of Rocky Horror Picture Show fame) may sound kitsch, but they are utterly terrifying. As the film proved, there was more to Hammer horror than just sapphic vampires or reworkings of Frankenstein.







Romance: Brief Encounter

It is so frightfully, frightfully unfair to say anything unpleasant about David Lean's Brief Encounter, above), with its scenes of Celia Johnson and Trevor Howard making calf eyes at each other on railway platforms, as Rachmaninov blasts away on the soundtrack.

One might argue, though, that British romantic movies carried more of a charge when they were less polite and emotionally restrained. The critics may have liked Brief Encounter but the real hits at the box-office in the 1940s were the Gainsborough melodramas. As one reviewer noted of bodice-rippers such as The Wicked Lady and The Man In Grey, the formula was usually pretty much the same. "Spectacle and sex, a dash of sadism, near-the-knuckle lines and an end where virtue is rewarded."

The Gainsborough romances boasted big cleavages, tight corsets and Margaret Lockwood up to mischief. James Mason was always skulking in the background, ready to punish her for her misdemeanours.







Thrillers: Goldfinger

It seems perverse to celebrate British thrillers without acknowledging that jowly genius from Leytonstone, Alfred Hitchcock, patron saint of the genre. Goldfinger is a middling Bond movie, mainly notable for introducing Sean Connery to golf and for the lethal, frisbee-throwing antics of Oddjob. It is not a patch, though, on the vintage Hitchcock thrillers of the 1930s, The Lady Vanishes and The 39 Steps, above. The former offered us Michael Redgrave as a very schoolmasterly action-hero and Basil Radford and Naunton Wayne discussing the cricket, even as their train was attacked in the wilds of continental Europe. The latter boasted the gorgeous Madeleine Carroll, one of the first of Hitchcock's glacial blondes, handcuffed to Robert Donat in the Scottish Highlands.

Goldfinger was directed by Guy Hamilton, who learnt most of his tricks while working as an assistant director on what is widely acknowledged as the greatest British thriller of all - Carol Reed's The Third Man.

If you had to choose between Fort Knox (scene of the denouement of Goldfinger) and the sewers of Vienna (where The Third Man ends), the Austrian rats would win every time.





War: The Dam Busters

The sign of a good British war film is that it will later be bowdlerised by advertisers who want to sell lager. This happened with both The Dam Busters (the title chosen for the Summer of British Film) and Ice Cold In Alex. The Brits made so many war films in the 1950s that they sometimes risk blurring into one neverending movie in which John Mills does his patriotic bit while Sylvia Syms is sweating in the desert.

One of the best British forays into the genre was surely In Which We Serve (1942), directed by Noel Coward and David Lean. It may seem old-fashioned now, but it was formally innovative (check out Lean's use of ripple dissolves), was made in the middle of the war and celebrated consensus and decency. Coward himself is on the pompous side as Captain Kinross (based on Louis Mountbatten) but the film hints at a world in which the old class distinctions no longer apply. (When you are clinging for your life to a raft, it no longer makes much difference where you went to school or what rank you hold.) There are doughty performances from those beneath decks, not least Bernard Miles as a long-suffering English everyman, and a very youngRichard Attenborough.







Alternatively...



Nick James, Editor of Sight and Sound magazine

THRILLER

Defence of the Realm

Still gives you that cold war chill.





ROMANCE

I Know Where I'm Going

Quirky tale of a dreamy bride-to-be in the Western Isles.





SOCIAL REALISM

Nil By Mouth

The most powerful film about working-class London ever.





COSTUME DRAMA

House of Mirth

Shatteringly poignant.





HORROR

Shaun of the Dead

I'm hard to scare, so my kind of horror makes you laugh.





WAR

The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp

Stirs the right kind of anti-war patriotism in me.





COMEDY

Kind Hearts and Coronets

The epitome of deadpan.











Barry Norman, Film critic

THRILLER

The Third Man

Beautifully acted and directed.



ROMANCE

I Know Where I'm Going

A lovely Powell and Pressburger romance.



SOCIAL REALISM

Trainspotting

Said a hell of a lot about Britain.





COSTUME DRAMA

Henry V

I have equal regard for Brannagh and Olivier's versions.





HORROR

Don't Look Now

Sends shivers up my spine.





WAR

The Cruel Sea

A wonderful film, and my father produced it.





COMEDY

Kind Hearts and Coronets

Has a sharp, biting and cynical humour.











DAN JOLIN

Features editor, Empire magazine

THRILLER

Dead Man's Shoes

Meadows is a fantastic talent.





ROMANCE

A Matter of Life and Death

You can't get more romantic.





SOCIAL REALISM

Scum

Harsh social realism which was Ray Winstone's calling card.





COSTUME DRAMA

Witch Finder General

Usually categorised as horror.





HORROR

The Descent

White knuckle stuff.





WAR

Lawrence of Arabia

What better than a film that Steven Spielberg watches before he goes into a new project?





COMEDY

Brazil

Surreal science fiction comedy.















Hannah McGill, Director of the Edinburgh International Film Festival, which launches today

THRILLER

Brighton Rock

Almost unbearably tense.





ROMANCE

Gregory's Girl

Innocent yet clever: what's not to fall in love with?





COSTUME DRAMA

Great Expectations

Once seen, never forgotten - every element here is stunning.





SOCIAL REALISM

This Sporting Life

Anderson was a genius.





HORROR

An American Werewolf in London

Still unbeaten.





WAR

A Matter of Life and Death

About redemption and hope rather than battlefield glory.





COMEDY

The Man in the White Suit

A perfect satire.

[DB7]

These are a few alternative and personal selections not mentioned. Thriller would probably be Get Carter, Comedy nod would go to Oh Mr Porter or a Carry On and Horror to Dead of Night

[The Wicked Gentleman]

Nobody heard of Monty Python?

[batman]

A few suggestions ....



Thriller - 3rd Man/Brighton Rock

Costume - Gone to Earth

Horror - Dracula/Dead of Night

Social Realism - The Angry Silence

Comedy - Oh Mr Porter

Romance - Truly Madly Deeply

War - The Small Back Room



Bats.

[DB7]

For War Film I'd go with their second choice; Ice Cold in Alex. Just watching it makes you thirsty for a cool lager.

[batman]

name='DB7']For War Film I'd go with their second choice; Ice Cold in Alex. Just watching it makes you thirsty for a cool lager.

I think the scene in Small Back Room with Mr Farrar and his 'giant' bottle is a good companion for that scene.



Bats.

[orpheum]

the dam busters is on Channel 4 this Saturday at 4.40pm

[Wolfgang]

I like Barry Norman's list best, except Billy Liar edges out Trainspotting in my book. He probably felt obligated to put something modern in.

[Wolfgang]

Dan Jolin's list is awful.

[Joenoir]

Thriller: The 39 Steps

Costume: Richard III

Horror: Dead of Night

Social Realism: Saturday Night and Sunday Morning

Comedy: The Green Man

Romance: Brief Encounter

War: Next of Kin

Musical: A Hard Day's Night

Comingofage: Quadraphenia

Scifi: Quatermass

Silent: Piccadilly

[Steve Crook]

name='Wolfgang']Dan Jolin's list is awful.

With A Matter of Life and Death and Scum?

What would your list be?



Mine could well be:

Thriller: A Matter of Life and Death / Black Narcissus

Costume: Gone to Earth

Horror: Peeping Tom

Social Realism: The Battle of the River Plate

Comedy: The Elusive Pimpernel

Romance: A Matter of Life and Death / I Know Where I'm Going!

War: A Matter of Life and Death / The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp / I Know Where I'm Going!

Musical: The Red Shoes / The Tales of Hoffmann

Coming of age: Age of Consent

Scifi: The Boy Who Turned Yellow

Silent: The Magician



Or is that a bit biased?



Steve

[Windthrop]

The fact that there can be so many relavent choices in each category does at least prove the rich heritage of British film - heres my take



Thriller - Green for Danger

Horror - Night of the Demon

Costume - Tom Jones

Comedy - I'm All Right Jack

Social Realism - A Kind of Loving

War - Zulu

Sci Fi - Quatermass and the Pit

Musical - Oh What a Lovely War !

Romance - I know Where I'm Going

[Carmel]

Everyone has their own favorites so most people will have a different lists, i personally loved the Haunted the original version as a really good horror and up the junction i loved that as well as a drama, which neither was mentioned so there is my point.

[oldmantv]

I totally agree with the Wicker man, Henry V and Goldfingers.........

[stevie boy]

name='Steve Crook']With A Matter of Life and Death and Scum?

What would your list be?



Mine could well be:

Thriller: A Matter of Life and Death / Black Narcissus

Costume: Gone to Earth

Horror: Peeping Tom

Social Realism: The Battle of the River Plate

Comedy: The Elusive Pimpernel

Romance: A Matter of Life and Death / I Know Where I'm Going!

War: A Matter of Life and Death / The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp / I Know Where I'm Going!

Musical: The Red Shoes / The Tales of Hoffmann

Coming of age: Age of Consent

Scifi: The Boy Who Turned Yellow

Silent: The Magician



Or is that a bit biased?



Steve

Steve, your fave is AMOLAD, what is your number 2???, I would guess IKWIG. Am I right???

[hankoler]

Thriller - 10 RILLINGTON PLACE

Romance - A MATTER OF LIFE AND DEATH

War - THE CRUEL SEA and MARK HER NAME WITH PRIDE

[Steve Crook]

name='stevie boy']Steve, your fave is AMOLAD, what is your number 2???, I would guess IKWIG. Am I right???

It's always difficult to pick my second favourite.

It would have to be a "second equal" award between Colonel Blimp, A Canterbury Tale and IKWIG. And they're not very far behind AMOLAD in my estimation, but for me, AMOLAD just about takes the prize in so many ways.



And then the "third (or is it fifth) equal" would be between The Red Shoes, Black Narcissus, 49th Parallel, Edge of the World, The Small Back Room and maybe a few non P&P films could get in at that level



Steve

[Harleybloke]

Comedy - The Full Monty

Costume - A Man for all Seasons / Cromwell

Social Realism - Trainspotting

Fantasy - A Grand Day Out

Romance - Love Actually

Thriller - The Long Good Friday

War - The Dam Busters