Quote:
Originally Posted by ChristineCB
I haven't seen this one on the library shelves, but I'm wondering if you've an opinion about the quality of the following three books:
Kinsey's HAMMER: THE BRAY STUDIO YEARS
Meikle's HISTORY OF HORROR RISE & FALL OF HAMMER
Hutchings' HAMMER & BEYOND HISTORY OF BRITISH HORROR
I'm going to pick up one of them but, often with such works, if one disappoints me, I end up losing interest and a desire to do further 'research' reading (mostly because I ain't doing real research for a purpose)!
|
All three are worth your time - but for very different reasons.
Meikle's is, IMHO, the best single volume history of Hammer. There are a few errors (I understand) but nothing particularly struck me. It's a good overview of Hammer's whole history, and manages a decent mix of production history and analysis - although tending towards the former. And it's very readable.
Kinsey's book is fantastic - but only covers the Bray years (up to The Mummy's Shroud). Enormously detailed, especially some really useful material on the BBFC, but it's strictly chronological narrative means that Film A is in production, Film B is in Production, Film A has a run in with the Censor, Film B has production problems, Film C is started, Film A is re-edited.... Not as easy a read as the Meikle, but for depth it's unrivalled - and is a bit stronger on analysis of the films. I haven't read his follow up yet, but it is high on my wants list.
Huchings' book is mistitled - basically it's an update of David Pirie's
A Heritage of Horror (very highly recommended if you can find a copy - still the most important and referenced work in the field) with added psychoanalytical theory. It can be hard work in places, and I have serious disagreements in many places with him, but if you have a background in film theory it's worth a look. I have to say, Hutchings' later books (on Terence Fisher and
Dracula) are rather better, especially the latter.
The Meikle is expensive and the Hutchings out of print - the Kinsey might be the one to go for (or, if you can get a decently priced copy, the Meikle if you don't want to be overwhelmed by the detail).