
Originally Posted by
Pricey
I've spoken about this already on another thread, but here we go:-
Goldfinger invites all the hoods to his HQ and explains to them all in fine detail all the aspects of his plan. One hood, Mr Solo, decides to pass and leaves early. He gets killed and crushed in his car. All the other hoods, presumably still happy to co-operate and now fully briefed on the plan, are then nevertheless all gassed and killed en masse back at the briefing.
This makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. Why take the trouble to theatrically kill the one who walks, in the process presumably having to recover his share of the gold from the crushed car, when you planned to kill them all anyway? Why explain your evil plan when you planned to kill them all anyway? I first saw this film when I was about ten and even then I went "What??!!" at this scene.
In the book all those who don't decide to pass are included in the gang, which of course makes perfect sense.
Otherwise I agree it is pretty much your perfect Bond film...